LEGO Super Mario character pack values range from under $2 for common characters like Fuzzy up to $25 or more for scarcer figures like Amp, with sealed blind bags often commanding a premium over loose, identified figures when the character inside turns out to be a known chase pull. Six main series have released since the Super Mario theme launched in 2020, and value depends heavily on which wave a character came from, how common it was, and whether the bag was ever opened.
I started tracking these packs seriously after noticing how often sellers lump every blind bag character into one price bucket. That is a mistake. In my experience, the spread between a Series 1 Fuzzy and a Series 3 Amp is more than 15 times, and that gap only gets wider as the older series become harder to find still sealed.
Key takeaways:
- brick'em's catalog currently tracks 230 individual Super Mario minifigures across six series, with used prices ranging from about $1.50 to over $24.
- Series 1 and Series 2 characters generally sell lower today, often $1.50 to $5 used, because they were produced in the largest numbers.
- Sealed, unopened packs can sell for multiples of the loose figure price when the character inside turns out to be a harder pull, like Poison Mushroom from Series 2.
- Rarity inside a wave matters more than the wave number itself. Several Series 5 and Series 6 figures already outvalue most of Series 1 and Series 2.
What Are LEGO Super Mario Character Packs Worth Right Now?
LEGO Super Mario character packs, also called blind bags or power up packs, currently sell for anywhere between about $1.50 and $25 used, depending on the character and series. Common figures like Fuzzy or Bob-omb from Series 1 sit at the low end, while scarcer pulls like Amp from Series 3 sit closer to $25.
That range is wide on purpose. LEGO never printed character names on the outside of these packs, so every wave shipped as a true mystery, with common characters packed far more often than rare ones. The result, six series and roughly 60 unique characters later, is a secondary market that behaves a lot like trading cards. A seller I know who sorts loose Mario figures by the bucket says the biggest mistake new sellers make is pricing every figure the same instead of checking each one individually against brick'em's LEGO minifigure database before listing.
How Do Blind Bag Character Packs Get Their Value?
Value comes down to three things: how many of a character LEGO produced, how recognizable that character is to Mario fans, and whether the figure is still sealed in its original bag. A character like Bowser or Luigi, pulled from a core mainline set rather than a blind bag, tends to hold steadier demand than a one off enemy character most casual buyers have never heard of.
From what I've seen, the biggest swings happen around characters that look nearly identical to a more common variant. Dry Bowser, for example, reads as a rarer, more dramatic version of the standard Bowser figure, and that visual distinction alone pushes demand and price well above a typical enemy character.
Series 1 and Series 2: The Original Mario Waves
Series 1 and Series 2 character packs are generally the most affordable Mario minifigures today, with most individual characters trading for $1.50 to $5 used, because LEGO produced the largest volume of these early waves when the theme first launched in 2020. A handful of characters even then carry a premium if they tie closely to a specific level mechanic or stand out visually.
Fuzzy, one of the most common Series 1 pulls, often sells for close to $1.50 used, while Peepa from that same wave runs closer to $3.80. Series 2 follows a similar pattern for most characters, but Poison Mushroom stands out. It typically moves for around $2.61 used, yet sealed, new in package copies have sold for as much as $16.82, more than six times the loose price. That gap tells you something important: condition and packaging can matter more than the series number itself.
Which Series 3 and Series 4 Characters Command the Highest Prices?
Series 3 produced the single highest value character pack figure in the lineup so far: Amp, which regularly sells for around $24.73 used, making it the standout chase figure of the entire Super Mario minifigure line. Series 4 runs more moderately, with most characters landing in the $4 to $12 range depending on condition.
In my experience, Amp's price holds up because it looks dramatically different from a standard enemy figure, with a glowing ring design that photographs well for resale listings. Mechakoopa, also from Series 4, trades around $12.28 used, making it one of the stronger performers in that wave. If you are deciding which packs to prioritize sourcing out of a Facebook Marketplace lot or a bulk flip, Series 3 and Series 4 are worth a closer look before Series 1 or Series 2.
Series 5 and Series 6: The Newer Waves to Watch
Series 5 and Series 6 are the most recent Mario character pack waves, and several of their figures already out earn most of the older series, which suggests collector demand is still building rather than fading. Blue Shy Guy and Red Yoshi, both from Series 5, are two of the clearest examples of that trend.
Blue Shy Guy sells for about $10 used but has reached roughly $34.10 new in its sealed packaging, one of the widest new versus used spreads in the entire theme. Red Yoshi follows a similar curve, at $11.82 used and up to $28.57 new. I personally think this new versus used gap is the single most useful signal for anyone deciding whether to keep packs sealed for resale or open them to sell characters individually.
Does a Sealed Pack Sell for More Than a Loose Figure?
Yes, in many cases a sealed, unopened Mario character pack sells for more than the identified loose figure inside, especially when that figure turns out to be a scarcer pull like Amp, Red Yoshi, or Poison Mushroom. Buyers pay a premium for the mystery and the unopened packaging itself, not just the plastic character.
That premium is not universal, though. If the pack contains a common character like Fuzzy or Bob-omb, a buyer who already owns an identification tool can often tell what is inside just by weight or scan code, and will pay closer to loose price. I recommend checking your sealed packs against the brick'em LEGO minifigure database before deciding whether to sell them sealed or open them yourself.
Super Mario Character Pack Value Cheat Sheet
Here is a quick reference for where each series generally lands on price, based on current catalog data. Treat these as typical ranges rather than guarantees, since individual listings vary by condition, completeness, and platform.
| Series | Typical Used Range | Standout Character | Standout Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Series 1 | $1.50 to $4 | Peepa | $3.80 used |
| Series 2 | $2 to $6 | Poison Mushroom | $16.82 new |
| Series 3 | $5 to $25 | Amp | $24.73 used |
| Series 4 | $4 to $12 | Mechakoopa | $12.28 used |
| Series 5 | $5 to $34 | Blue Shy Guy | $34.10 new |
| Series 6 | $5 to $10 | Birdo | $10.78 new |
If you are trying to put a number on an entire lot of mixed series packs, running the batch through brick'em's haul calculator is faster than pricing each character by hand, especially when you are evaluating a bulk buy on the spot.
How Can You Tell If a Mario Figure Is a Chase Character?
A Mario figure is generally considered a chase character when it sells consistently above the average price for its series, shows up less often in bulk lots, and has a visually distinct design compared to the more common characters in that same wave. Amp, Red Yoshi, and Blue Shy Guy all fit that pattern right now.
I've seen new sellers assume rarity based on how a character looks rather than how it actually sells. The safer approach is to check sold prices directly instead of guessing. When I sort through a new lot, I scan each figure and compare it against current data before setting a listing price, rather than relying on memory of what a character sold for months ago.
Where Should You Buy and Sell Mario Character Packs?
BrickLink tends to work best for selling individual, identified Mario characters at accurate market pricing, since it is the closest thing the hobby has to a standard price reference for LEGO minifigures. eBay and Whatnot both work well for sealed packs and small lots, where buyers are drawn in by the mystery factor and competitive bidding.
Facebook Marketplace and local lots are usually the best place to source Mario packs cheaply in the first place, often mixed in with other LEGO sets from people clearing out a kid's old collection. From what I've learned buying lots this way, sellers rarely know which characters they are holding, so a mixed box of twenty sealed packs can easily contain one or two characters worth more than the rest of the box combined. If you want a running total of what a growing Mario collection is worth, brick'em's collection value calculator adds it up as you go instead of making you track a spreadsheet by hand.
Heads up: This is not financial or legal advice. We're sharing what we've learned from the LEGO reselling community.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is a LEGO Super Mario character pack worth unopened?
An unopened LEGO Super Mario character pack is generally worth more than its average series price, since buyers are paying for the chance at a rare pull. Depending on series and odds, sealed packs have sold anywhere from about $5 up to $34, with the newer Series 5 and Series 6 waves currently commanding some of the highest sealed prices.
What is the rarest Super Mario LEGO minifigure?
Based on current resale data, Amp from Series 3 is one of the rarest and most valuable Super Mario minifigures, regularly selling for around $24.73 used. Blue Shy Guy and Red Yoshi from Series 5 are close behind, both reaching well over $25 when sold new in sealed packaging rather than loose.
Why are some Series 1 Mario figures worth so little?
Series 1 Mario figures were part of the very first wave LEGO released in 2020, and several characters like Fuzzy were produced in large numbers relative to collector demand. When supply outpaces how many buyers actively want a character, prices settle low, often around $1.50 to $3 used, even years later.
Should I sell Mario character packs sealed or opened?
It depends on the character. If scanning or identification suggests a common figure is inside, selling it loose after confirming the character often nets more per item. If you suspect a higher value chase figure, keeping it sealed and listing it as a mystery pack usually attracts a stronger price from buyers chasing that specific character.
Where can I check current LEGO Mario minifigure prices before I sell?
I recommend checking a tool that pulls current marketplace pricing, like brick'em's minifigure database, rather than relying on a sale from months ago. Prices on character packs move with collector interest, so confirming a number before you list saves you from underpricing a harder to find character.
.png)