LEGO CMF Series 9 values span a wide range depending on which of the 16 minifigures you pulled. Based on current BrickLink-integrated pricing in brick'em's catalog, used Series 9 figures run from around $2.98 (Policeman) up to $19.87 (Forest Maiden), while new or factory-sealed-quality figures stretch from about $4.49 up to roughly $37.18 for the same Forest Maiden. This 2013 series is one of the wider value spreads in the whole Collectible Minifigures line, and in my experience that spread is exactly why Series 9 lots still get picked over carefully by resellers instead of being sold off as a flat-rate bundle.
I pulled every Series 9 figure's current used and new pricing straight from brick'em's catalog before writing this, because guessing at individual minifigure values is how sellers leave money on the table. Below you'll find the full price breakdown, a look at why Forest Maiden and Heroic Knight sit well above the rest of the series, and a practical rundown of how to grade condition and pick a sales channel once you know what you're holding.
- Series 9 used values range from about $2.98 to $19.87, and new values range from about $4.49 to $37.18.
- Forest Maiden and Heroic Knight are the two clear standouts in the series.
- Policeman, Battle Mech, and Alien Avenger sit at the bottom of the value range.
- Condition and completeness (accessories, stand, original bag) swing these prices significantly.
- Where you sell a Series 9 figure matters almost as much as which figure it is.
What Is LEGO CMF Series 9, and Why Do Collectors Still Chase It?
LEGO Collectible Minifigures Series 9 is a 16-figure blind-bag series released back in 2013, built around a grab bag of original characters like a Roman Emperor, a one-eyed Cyclops, and a Mermaid, rather than licensed characters from a movie or show. Collectors keep chasing it because the series is old enough to be genuinely scarce in complete, undamaged condition, and because a few figures in the lineup carry real character appeal that's held up over a decade later.
I've seen a lot of CMF series come and go, and Series 9 is a good teaching example because it has such a clear top tier and bottom tier. That's useful if you're trying to understand how value actually gets assigned inside a single series instead of assuming every figure from the same wave is worth roughly the same amount. It almost never is.
Heads up: This is not financial or legal advice. We're sharing what we've learned from the LEGO reselling community.
How Much Is Each LEGO Series 9 Minifigure Worth Right Now?
Every Series 9 minifigure has its own used and new price, and the gap between the cheapest and most expensive figure in the series is more than six times. Here's the full breakdown pulled from brick'em's BrickLink-integrated pricing data, sorted from highest to lowest used value, so you can quickly see where any figure you're holding lands.
| Minifigure | BrickLink ID | Used (avg) | New (avg) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Forest Maiden | col143 | $19.87 | $37.18 |
| Heroic Knight | col132 | $17.92 | $28.03 |
| Fortune Teller | col137 | $13.67 | $24.00 |
| Hollywood Starlet | col131 | $10.32 | $12.47 |
| Judge | col138 | $7.49 | $11.03 |
| Roman Emperor | col133 | $7.29 | $15.99 |
| Mermaid | col140 | $6.55 | $10.31 |
| Roller Derby Girl | col136 | $6.28 | $4.49 |
| Waiter | col129 | $6.08 | $10.19 |
| Cyclops | col130 | $5.91 | $12.13 |
| Chicken Suit Guy | col135 | $5.20 | $10.21 |
| Plumber | col144 | $5.19 | $7.54 |
| Mr. Good and Evil | col142 | $3.72 | $9.06 |
| Alien Avenger | col139 | $3.61 | $7.36 |
| Battle Mech | col141 | $3.44 | $5.75 |
| Policeman | col134 | $2.98 | $6.99 |
A couple of these are worth flagging. Judge has one of the widest used price ranges I've noticed in the series, selling anywhere from about $3.79 to $15.13 depending on condition, which tells you condition matters more for that figure than most others. Roller Derby Girl is also unusual because her used price actually sits above her new average, which can happen when sealed/new supply for a lower-demand figure is thin relative to loose demand. When I sort a mixed Series 9 lot, I check against pricing like this figure by figure instead of eyeballing it, and you can run the same lookup yourself through brick'em's LEGO minifigure database.
Which Series 9 Minifigure Is Worth the Most?
Forest Maiden is the most valuable standard figure in LEGO CMF Series 9, averaging around $19.87 used and up to $37.18 new. She's the clear top of the series by a meaningful margin over the next closest figure, Heroic Knight, and that gap has held up over years of resale data rather than being a short-term spike.
In my view, Forest Maiden's value comes down to a mix of lower perceived pull odds among collectors who were chasing this series back in 2013 and a design that's aged well with the nature-fantasy collector crowd. I personally think she's still a little underpriced relative to how often I see sellers struggle to find her complete with her bow and leaf accessories intact. A seller I know who specializes in CMF lots told me he pulls Forest Maiden out of any bulk box the moment he spots the head sculpt, before he even checks the torso.
What Is the Heroic Knight Worth, and Why Does It Price So High?
The Heroic Knight from Series 9 averages about $17.92 used and $28.03 new, making it the second most valuable figure in the series. Pricing this high usually comes from a combination of strong armor detailing, a popular shield and sword accessory set, and consistent demand from both CMF collectors and castle-theme builders who want the figure for display rather than as a loose minifigure.
I started tracking individual CMF values years ago mainly because of figures like this one. A knight or soldier-type figure with good armor print tends to outperform civilian figures in the same series almost every time, and Series 9 is a clean example of that pattern holding up.
What Are the Cyclops, Mermaid, and Chicken Suit Guy Worth Today?
Cyclops averages roughly $5.91 used and $12.13 new, Mermaid averages about $6.55 used and $10.31 new, and Chicken Suit Guy averages close to $5.20 used and $10.21 new. All three sit in the middle-to-lower tier of Series 9 values, which surprises some sellers given how recognizable all three figures are.
I noticed that recognizability and resale value don't always line up, and these three figures are a good example. Cyclops and Chicken Suit Guy are both instantly identifiable even to non-collectors, but neither one commands Forest Maiden or Heroic Knight money. From what I've seen reselling novelty-costume and creature figures across multiple CMF series, that pattern repeats: a fun, memorable figure isn't automatically a high-value one. I use brick'em's scanner to check figures like these against live pricing before I ever list them, because it's easy to overprice a figure just because it's a fan favorite.
What Is Mr. Good and Evil Worth Compared to the Rest of the Series?
Mr. Good and Evil averages about $3.72 used, with a documented range of roughly $2.32 to $6.23, and around $9.06 new. That places him in the bottom third of Series 9 values, well below the series' standout figures and even below several of the more plain-looking civilian designs.
I found that two-sided or gimmick figures like Mr. Good and Evil often underperform their novelty factor, and this one is a solid case study. The double-sided head is a fun printing trick, but it hasn't translated into the kind of sustained collector demand that keeps a figure's price elevated a decade out. If you're building out a value calculator for a mixed box that includes him, brick'em's LEGO collection value calculator is a faster way to get a realistic number than averaging guesses across the lot.
How Should You Grade Condition Before You Price a Series 9 Figure?
Condition grading for a 2013-era CMF figure like this comes down to checking the print, the plastic, and completeness before you touch a price guide. A figure that's missing an accessory or has visible wear on the print can drop 20 to 40 percent below the average used price shown above, so grading first keeps you from under- or over-listing.
- Check for crisp, unscratched facial and torso printing under direct light.
- Confirm all original accessories are present (weapons, headgear, stands if sold complete).
- Look for yellowing or sun-fading on light-colored plastic, common on decade-old figures.
- Test leg and arm joints for looseness or stress marks at the hip and arm sockets.
- Separate "minifigure only" listings from "complete with stand and accessories" listings, since brick'em and BrickLink both price these differently.
In my experience, sellers who skip this step end up pricing a rougher figure at the clean-condition average, which either kills the sale or leads to return requests. It takes thirty seconds per figure and it's worth doing every time.
Is a Series 9 Lot Worth Buying to Resell, and Where Should You Sell It?
A Series 9 lot can be worth buying to resell if the price you're paying per figure sits well under the blended average across the 16-figure lineup, which lands somewhere around $8 to $9 used per figure once you average the whole table above. Where you sell individual figures afterward matters almost as much as the purchase price.
BrickLink is the one I lean on for accurate, figure-by-figure pricing since it's basically the Wall Street of LEGO when it comes to tracking what individual minifigures actually sell for. eBay tends to move Series 9 figures fast when they're priced thirty to fifty percent under current market value, especially bundled sets of three or four figures rather than singles. Whatnot works best if you're building an audience around live LEGO sales and can bundle a Forest Maiden or Heroic Knight as a show highlight rather than selling it cold. Facebook Marketplace and estate-sale type sourcing are usually where the cheap bulk lots containing Series 9 figures show up in the first place, long before they ever reach a dedicated LEGO buyer.
When I'm running the math on a bulk lot that might contain Series 9 figures mixed in with other series, I run it through brick'em's haul calculator before I commit to a purchase price, since guessing at blended lot value is how resellers overpay. I recommend doing the same any time you're buying sealed boxes or bags sight-unseen, since Series 9 bags look identical from the outside and you won't know your blend of high-value and low-value figures until they're open.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the rarest figure in LEGO CMF Series 9?
Forest Maiden is generally considered the standout figure in Series 9, averaging around $19.87 used and up to $37.18 new. Heroic Knight is a close second at roughly $17.92 used. Both outpace the rest of the 16-figure lineup by a wide margin, which is why experienced sellers check for these two first in any mixed lot.
How much is a used Series 9 Cyclops worth?
A used Series 9 Cyclops averages around $5.91, with new or sealed-quality examples averaging closer to $12.13. That puts Cyclops in the middle of the Series 9 value range, below standouts like Forest Maiden and Heroic Knight but above the series' lowest-value figures like Policeman and Battle Mech.
Is LEGO CMF Series 9 a good series to collect for resale?
Series 9 is a reasonable resale target because of its wide value spread, roughly $2.98 to $19.87 used across the lineup, which rewards sellers who sort and price figure by figure instead of selling a lot as a flat bundle. It's not the highest-ceiling series in the CMF line, but the spread makes careful sorting worthwhile.
Why do some Series 9 figures sell for so much more than others?
Value differences inside the same series usually come down to character appeal, accessory desirability, and how often collectors were actively chasing that specific figure back when the series released in 2013. Armor and fantasy-themed figures like Heroic Knight and Forest Maiden tend to outperform plainer civilian designs within the same lineup.
Where is the best place to sell LEGO Series 9 minifigures?
BrickLink is generally the most reliable place for accurate, per-figure pricing on Series 9 minifigures, while eBay can move figures quickly when priced thirty to fifty percent under market. Whatnot works well for bundling higher-value figures like Forest Maiden into a live show rather than selling them as a quiet single listing.
CTA(Identify%20and%20Price%20100%2B%20Figures%20With%20One%20Pic).png)